Insuring Florida

Find out why your neighbors are referring their friends to us!

Sebastian Insurance, Inc., has been insuring families and businesses in Indian River Country for long enough that it's become a household name!

Our success is built upon the reputation we've earned for providing the best insurance value at an affordable cost. That's the reason so much of our growth comes from referrals from satisfied customers.

We'll be here when you need us!

About Us

Our Sebastian, Florida, office was opened in 1988 with a clear focus on serving the needs of individuals, families and small businesses in Indian River County. We are proud to have earned a reputation for honest, attentive and personal customer service. That's why so much of our growth comes from referrals of others who've selected us as their personal insurance agency.

At Sebastian Insurance, we believe that our mission is solely that of serving the needs of our customers, without whom we would not exist. That's why we take time to explain coverages and consistently challenge ourselves to listen to our customers. We realize that it's important to demonstrate our caring attitude by following through on our commitments.

Old fashioned? You bet! Simple approach? Absolutely! Sounds too good to be true? Put us to the test!

Donna A. Keys

A resident of Sebastian for over 25 years, Donna started Sebastian Insurance, Inc. in 1988. She is a Certified Financial Planner and a Certified Insurance Counselor. She is experienced in both personal and commercial property and casualty insurance. Donna is very involved in the community and has served as a member of the board of directors for the Sebastian River Area Chamber of Commerce, Indian River Council on Aging, and the Exchange Club of Sebastian. "Our agency has a great reputation for service. We have worked hard to earn that reputation and will do whatever it takes to keep it."

Kathleen Neuhaus, CSR

Kathy was born and raised in East Hampton, NY. She began her insurance career there in 1982 in the Commercial Lines Department of the E. F. Cook Agency. She earned her New York State Brokers License in 1987. Kathy moved to Florida, along with her husband, in 1990 and continued her career in insurance, earning her Customer Service Representative license in 1991. Kathy has been with Sebastian Insurance for over five years and is now the Commercial Lines Manager. "I pride myself in the way I service our customers' insurance needs, hopefully conveying a courteous and friendly atmosphere to all."

Amy J. Pryor, Agent

Amy was born and raised in Wilbraham, Ma. and relocated to Florida in 1998. She began her insurance career in 1999 as a personal lines insurance agent and joined Sebastian Insurance in September 2006. "I am excited about working at Sebastian Insurance, a very professional, fast growing agency, an agency where the customers come first."

Kasey N. Spivey, Agent

Kasey is a life long resident of Indian River County. After attending college, she began her insurance career and specialized in homeowners and auto insurance. Kasey joined Sebastian Insurance in 2007 and continues to excel in the personal lines market. "I enjoy being part of an agency with a long-standing tradition of commitment to our clients and our community. "